June 9, 2014—Fearlessly Archived—Still a fun read; price & availability may have changed.
Trader Joe's Sublime Ice Cream Sandwiches came to fruition after months and months of tasting and re-tasting by our panel. (Yes, it's a messy job, but we're pretty sure we're up to the task.) When the chocolate chip cookies finally reached the proper crunchy-chewy ratio, we moved on to the ice cream. After a few go-rounds, we landed on the ideal combination of cookie and ice cream. Then, of course, we had to make them even better. So we rolled the sides in mini, semi-sweet chocolate chips. End result? These Ice Cream Sandwiches have truly earned their Sublime moniker. And they're sublimely priced at a mere $3.99 for a package of four (20 ounces). You'll find them - where else? - in our freezers.