Sutter's Formula Cookies
March 18, 2013—Fearlessly Archived—Still a fun read, price & availability may have changed.
Named for the American general on whose land gold was first discovered in northern California, Trader Joe's Sutter's Formula Cookies are among our best selling and longest running cookies. They're that good. While you won't find any actual gold in them, you do find precious beans: peanut and cacao. They are crumbly-chewy, freshly-baked peanut butter cookies, liberally studded with big nuggets of milk chocolate. They're as rich as their name suggests, but you don't need to be to enjoy them. Each 16 ounce bag is $4.49*, every day.
*Ounces, price and availability may vary by region. Currently Trader Joe's Sutter's Formula Cookies are $3.99 in our East Coast stores, and $4.49 in our West Coast stores. Trader Joe's Sutter’s Formula Cookies are not available in our Midwest and Southeast stores, though a similar product for $3.99 is available: Trader Joe's Peanut Butter & Chocolate Chip Cookies.